….

[The Batman] has multiple personalities that Regal had to crack at the script stage itself.

First is the character Batman himself.

Next is Bruce Wayne.

And the most important one is the city of Gotham.

Honestly, Regal had not encountered a script problem quite like this one in a while, and he was, and he was genuinely enjoying it.

The particular friction of a problem that resisted easy solutions was something he had learned, over six years of production, to recognise as a sign that the material was worth the difficulty.

Easy scripts were rarely the interesting ones.

However, the [Batman] introduction script had been working on for a while is giving him more trouble than the first [Spider-Man] had, which was saying something.

The [Spider-Man] script had its own specific challenge.

It was the opening entry of the entire MDCU, which meant every scene was doing double work, establishing character and establishing the rules of a universe simultaneously.

He had to spend hours and weeks on the framework alone, the connective tissue between what that film needed to be on its own terms and what it needed to set up for everything that came after.

And yet, [Batman] script seemed to prove more tricker to crack.

And the reason?

If he looked at it there were a lot of similarities between [Spider-man] and [Batman] from his previous world.

Ignoring the older versions, both the franchises have three different versions of Spider-man and Batman played by three different actors.

However, Regal still believes Spider-Man despite having three versions; and while fans may tend to split, he had to agree there is a clear dividend of acceptance among the fans.

Tobey Maguire was the original, the one people grew up with, the nostalgic anchor.

Andrew Garfield was widely considered the most faithful screen interpretation of the comic character; the wit, the science, the specific texture of Peter Parker as written.

And Tom Holland was….

Regal paused on that one, figuring out the category.

Maybe the most emotionally immediate and the one that made the youngest generation feel it was theirs.

He would come back to it.

The point was that Spider-Man's versions occupied distinct territories and the fan community, even in its most passionate disagreements, generally understood which territory each version owned.

You could have the argument and find the edges of it.

However, Batman had no such map.

Christian Bale's Batman, Ben Affleck's, Robert Pattinson's; these were not three takes on the same interpretation competing for primacy.

They were three entirely separate characters who happened to share a name, a trauma, and a suit.

The Wayne parents died in each of them, that was essentially where the shared ground ended.

The personalities and tones were distinct, and the scripts were built on different philosophical foundations.

The Gotham each of them inhabited felt like a different city that had been given the same name.

This was what made the Batman fan community's conversations genuinely difficult to navigate; not that they disagreed, but that they were frequently disagreeing about different things and didn't always know it.

Someone defending Bale and someone defending Pattinson were not really arguing about the same character.

They were arguing about which type of Batman story mattered more, which was a different argument entirely and one that had no resolution because both positions were legitimate.

Regal had filled twelve pages of a notepad with this problem over the previous two whole days.

The question wasn't which version of Batman to use; that had been settled in the MDCU's architecture long before the script became his immediate concern.

The question was what the specific version he was building demanded from its script, and what that script demanded from its director, and whether those two demands pointed toward the same person or two different ones.

He was fairly certain they pointed toward one person.

Hence the competition and the ongoing team discussions about how to run it.

The twelve pages of notes that were less a solution than a very thorough description of the problem.

He picked up his pen, turned to page thirteen and started writing.

….

Regal's pen moved across page thirteen determined to solve the Batman problem.

He had to look past the character's disparate cinematic history; the high-tech operatics of the Bale era, the weary brutality of Affleck, and the detective-noir isolation of Pattinson; and return to the foundational logic of Earth-1

On page thirteen, Regal inscribed the definitive map for his version: The Trauma-to-Transformation Arc.

Regal noted that while Spider-Man (Earth-616) was about the human scale of responsibility, Batman (Earth-1) had to be about the psychological utility of fear.

He wrote that the Gotham of his MDCU wouldn't just be another city; it would be an art deco monument to systemic decay, a place where corruption was so deeply rooted that only a 'mythic shadow' could disrupt it.

The script for this first entry, titled Batman Begins, would not be a standard origin story.

Instead, Regal mapped out a heavy focus on the League of Shadows training, ensuring Bruce Wayne's skills were presented as technique and discipline, not superhuman ability.

He decided the central conflict would be philosophical: Ra's al Ghul's belief that a corrupt system must be destroyed, versus Bruce Wayne's conviction that it must be reformed, one person at a time

….

[Two Weeks Later]

The script of [Batman] was almost done.

During the writing process of it, Regal had made choices he would claim as his boldest moves yet in his film slate of six years.

The first one was combining both the films:

[Batman Begins] and [The Dark Knight].

Both the films are part of the trilogy.

The first film established the man, while the second film tested everything the first film built, and the testing was the point, and the point was only legible if you had done the building first.

The problem was that making them as two separate films meant three films total, because the [Batman] as Regal had constructed it in the MDCU demanded a trilogy.

And three Batman films while other characters were still working through their first, some hadn't had a single entry yet and the second phase was still establishing the breadth of the universe; that was an imbalance he couldn't justify.

He sat with the problem for a week before the solution arrived.

Why not make it into one film?

The first chapter of the story is dedicated to Bruce Wayne and the League of Shadows; the origin, becoming, construction of Batman as a response to a specific kind of threat, with the Joker existing in the periphery of it.

He is present in the background, but not yet shown.

And then the film shifts.

The League's story concludes and the second chapter belongs entirely to the Joker; the full weight of him, the full philosophical confrontation, the thing that the first chapter had been quietly building toward.

It meant writing the largest script he had ever produced.

Larger than [Death Note], which remained the longest thing he had put on screen; and mind you it was supposed to be a show before he adapted it to a film.

And this would be longer than that.

He had already accepted that no matter how ruthlessly he cut, no matter how efficiently he structured, the final film was going to run somewhere between three hours and three hours twenty.

Possibly longer; the lengthiest film he had ever made, by a margin that was not close.

He was comfortable with this.

The runtime would justify itself or the script wasn't good enough, and he didn't intend to write a script that wasn't good enough.

The second bold choice was harder to make and took longer to arrive at.

He wanted to direct this film himself.

That desire was clear and simple and completely impractical given his current slate, and he had spent two weeks attempting to find a version of the schedule where it was possible before accepting, with the specific flatness of genuine acceptance rather than performed resignation, that it wasn't.

So he divided it.

The first chapter; Bruce Wayne, the League, the origin; would go to the director he selected through the competition.

The best person for that chapter of the story, whoever that turned out to be.

And the second chapter; the Joker, the confrontation, the philosophical engine of the whole film–

He would direct himself.

Though he had never split directorial credit on a film before.

He wasn't certain it had been done at this scale in quite this way before. His team will probably have concerns, which should be reasonable, but he is confident he could work through it.

Two directors.

One film.

Both chapters serve the same vision because he would be writing the script for both and producing the whole thing and one of the two directors would be him.

He wrote it down; put a circle around it, and left it there.

….

Which brought him to the two questions that were now the largest problems on his desk.

He had the structure and the scope.

What he did not have was–

Bruce Wayne, and the Joker.

Both questions were significant.

Bruce Wayne required a specific kind of actor; someone who could carry the physical transformation of the origin story, the grief underneath the discipline, the particular quality of a man who has weaponised his trauma so thoroughly he's no longer certain where the weapon ends and the person begins.

That was a difficult performance to find.

The Joker was a different order of problem.

Every version of the Joker that existed in any medium had staked out territory so completely that the next one had to find ground that hadn't been claimed yet; not as a rejection of what came before, but as a genuinely new argument about what the character was.

What made him frightening?

What made him, in the context of this specific story, the thing that could undo everything Bruce Wayne had constructed.

He needed someone who could make an audience feel, within the first five minutes of the Joker's full arrival in the second chapter, that the film had changed under their feet.

That the rules had shifted and whatever equilibrium the first chapter had built was no longer the relevant framework.

He needed someone who could do that without indicating that they were doing it.

….

.

[To be continued…]

●──────●◎●──────●

Author Note:

Visit Patreon to instantly access +1 chapter for free, available for Free Members as well.

For additional content please do support me and gain access to +15 more chapters.

--> [email protected]/OrgoWriters